|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 21:17:09 GMT -5
I'm surprised nothing else has been said.
|
|
|
Post by padmenic on Jul 15, 2014 21:36:20 GMT -5
im pretty sure he had a pm with you. He protected you... Why would he protect Dark? And wait, does this mean the protector was Boba? yeah genious. Smart going
|
|
|
Post by Kenbo on Jul 15, 2014 21:37:34 GMT -5
HEY I HEARD YOU WERE A WILD ONE OOH OOH OOH IF I TOOK YOU HOME YOUD BE A HOME RUN SHOW ME HOW YOU DO
|
|
|
Post by Namialus on Jul 15, 2014 21:47:59 GMT -5
VOTE TALLY:
Kyronn - 1
VOTING WILL CLOSE IN A MATTER OF MINUTES. You may send in your night actions beginning now.
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 21:53:24 GMT -5
VOTE: BANE
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 21:53:44 GMT -5
Sorry buddy, but I can't wait any longer
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:05:12 GMT -5
1. Why did I vote Boba? I voted Boba because I felt that he probably lied to Nic about a role. Since she even said it wasn't protector basically once or twice, I began to feel that maybe Boba had lied to her so he could take advantage of her power and be trusted. This would greatly benefit the scum. Nic is also a newer player, so he probably would've had a better chance of fooling her. Bane even admitted the same thing happened to him his first time as inspector and he had more games under his belt before that too, so that supports what I said above even more. The fact that Nic was already in contact with 4 (5?) people by day 2 and thought they were all loyal continues to prove this. I just thought that she was probably trusting some too much. Another thing as well, is that Neean played similar to how he did last game (for deny that Bane. You said it yourself). So therefore, couldn't Boba have pulled another one of those claiming a role he doesn't have things again? Just another thought I had that led to me voting him. 2. Why did I think a double vote would be better? I thought it'd be better because, honestly, I didn't trust the role claims of Boba or Wampa. I just thought Wampa might be less of a threat if he was scum compared to Boba (since he was greatly trusted by Nic) along with all my thoughts for voting Boba in the above question. I mean, Wampa claiming like that seemed like a scummy move to me, but also, let me just say that it turned out he was a loyal. I could do the same thing he did and claim my role, but I *know* that everyone would think that it would make me seem scummier so that's why I haven't bothered. But the main point of why I thought a double vote would be better is because it'd give us more information like yesterday. Wampa and Bane supported it so much yesterday, and now Bane is acting like it's the worst idea ever. Wampa on the other hand... Was voted off as a result of another one and he was loyal. Don't make the same mistake with me. I'm loyal and thought a double conviction would help more, especially when I thought both suspects were almost equally suspicious. 3. Reasons I'm loyal A) I voted Newan early on. If I was scum, I wouldn't have done that, or at least waited a little longer. B) Assuming Newan was the killer (as there have been no deaths lately) wouldn't that make me less wanting to vote him? C) Not to mention that Pinda already had two votes when I voted Newan. If I was scum, I would've went with Bane and voted Pinda. Then Pinda would've had more votes. But I didn't, which would be a stupid move on my part if I was scum. D) Newan pushed for Pinda and me a lot. If I was scum, why would he push for me that much? I understand if he brought it up once or twice, but he constantly brought up how he was suspicious of me and thought I was scum. Scum wouldn't be that stupid to be the ones to always bring up suspicions against another member, especially when there was a bigger suspect (Pinda). E) Also, if I was scum, would I be so stupid as to do the whole "accuse the main one accusing you" thing? Cause apparently you think I'm doing that against Bane. But regardless of whether or not I am, that's be really predictable of a scum, also making me stupid. F) Potato was killed on night 1. That was obviously an attempt to frame me and Pinda. The scum were smart enough to realize that by killing Tater, it'd make Pinda suspicous (since he was kinda against/suspicous of Tater). It'd make me suspicous too, since Tater voted me and it'd make it look like I was trying to get back at the first person to bring up suspicions against me. It's just too obvious of something for me to do as a scum. My team wouldn't jepprdize me like that, especially that early on. If I was really scum, they probably would've killed another threat like Spider, etc. G) No one has been close to me this whole game (except maybe Pinda or Wampa *slightly*). So even if I'm voted, you won't have much of an idea of who to go for since I have no one close to me and pretty much everyone against me. Whereas if you voted someone else, at least they'd probably give you a better idea of who to go for next. 1. Yup, because Nic would have told the whole group that Boba actually claimed Protector. Who says that wasn't just a cover? Because that would be a good strategy. Also, it wasn't the first time I was inspector. It was another time. And Even if it was, I'm pretty sure that Nic is better than I was when I was just starting playing. See proven that Severus times to me in this game. Anyway, yes, I did say that about Newan. But while anyone can claim a fake role, I seen too many other people use Newan's strategy. 2. Wow, hinting at a role, classy. But really that just makes you seem more suspicious to me. And don't try and bend my words. I said nothing about being the worst idea ever. And anyway stop subtly pushing for me. If you have something to say, say it.
|
|
|
Post by ?6 (CBK) on Jul 15, 2014 22:12:24 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal
VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR
|
|
|
Post by Namialus on Jul 15, 2014 22:14:32 GMT -5
Sorry, but I forgot the Day hasn't been up for over 24 hours. Therefore voting will remain open.
|
|
|
Post by ?6 (CBK) on Jul 15, 2014 22:16:41 GMT -5
I thought voting was going to be over so now I just rushed a vote.... Oh great.
|
|
|
Post by ?6 (CBK) on Jul 15, 2014 22:20:17 GMT -5
HEY I HEARD YOU WERE A WILD ONE OOH OOH OOH IF I TOOK YOU HOME YOUD BE A HOME RUN SHOW ME HOW YOU DO Oh Sia.... gotta love her
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 22:21:40 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR Honestly didn't expect that..... But thanks.
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:22:41 GMT -5
Now, if I'm fortunate enough to have no one else vote me, I think Bane is most suspicious. Here's why: A) He barely contributed to day 1 discussion. Just tried to be laid back and stay out of anyone's suspicions list. B) He pushed for a Pinda vote multiple times during voting on Day 3. And when Newan was racking up votes, he desperately wanted Wampa to come online ASAP and tie the votes so at least both would go. C) Bane did pretty much what a scum would do when their ally (Newan --- and possible killer) is about to be voted. He continued to say how Pinda was a better vote and so on. And don't give me that "I never pushed for Pinda; I just found him more suspicious" nonsense. You had to think that he was somewhat loyal to not vote for him, especially as the evidence against him became better and better. I'm telling you, Bane did almost what I said a scum would do in that scenario. Not me. D) Pinda suspected him. And Nic and others even agreed that he was suspicious. E) He found Boba suspicious for the same reasons I did but didn't vote him in the end. Once Nic kept telling him not to, he listened. But Nic isn't always right no matter how loyal she is. It's almost like he was afraid to go against her that day. But even if he wasn't "afraid", perhaps he made it seem like he believed her at the moment, so he could vote me (a loyal with some suspicions) when Wampa (who was most likely gonna be voted) or Boba (who may also be voted) would come up loyal, making him appear like a smart loyal and perhaps allow Nic and the rest to follow him on voting me. That just seemed odd to me. A: Barely contributed? Bitch please. And yes I had fun with the Castiel roleplay. But how do you connect that with me trying to stay off people's suspicion list? B: "multiple times"? "Desperately"? Bitch please. I made my case as to why a double conviction would be a good thing and then tagged him at the end. I just wanted him to see it. Nothing more, or less, than that. C: Oh really? What do you mean by that? Because people say things like "I just think they're a better choice" all the time regardless of affiliation. D: Yup, because Loyal dead players are always right. I got ya. Stop treating Pinda's word as scripture any time it suits you. E: "Nic isn't always right no matter how loyal she is." I'm glad you understand how Pinda Could be wrong about me, then, because that's the logic you're using in Nic's case. And honestly yes I did but I wasn't willing to risk voting a loyal, who claimed a role. And no, I'm not afraid to go against her. I disagreed with her on the Pinda Newan vote and plus we had a argument and I didn't back down from that either.
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:23:15 GMT -5
VOTE: STAR
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:23:42 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR Honestly didn't expect that..... But thanks. Yeah right.
|
|
|
Post by Namialus on Jul 15, 2014 22:23:46 GMT -5
VOTE TALLY:
The Conjuror - 2 Kyronn - 2
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:25:48 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR Been at work jsyk.
|
|
|
Post by ?6 (CBK) on Jul 15, 2014 22:27:41 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR Been at work jsyk. Sorry nam said voting would be over soon and I rushed into it (Before you posted responses to stars defense) And I just found you less loyal than Star was with his defense
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 22:28:06 GMT -5
Now, if I'm fortunate enough to have no one else vote me, I think Bane is most suspicious. Here's why: A) He barely contributed to day 1 discussion. Just tried to be laid back and stay out of anyone's suspicions list. B) He pushed for a Pinda vote multiple times during voting on Day 3. And when Newan was racking up votes, he desperately wanted Wampa to come online ASAP and tie the votes so at least both would go. C) Bane did pretty much what a scum would do when their ally (Newan --- and possible killer) is about to be voted. He continued to say how Pinda was a better vote and so on. And don't give me that "I never pushed for Pinda; I just found him more suspicious" nonsense. You had to think that he was somewhat loyal to not vote for him, especially as the evidence against him became better and better. I'm telling you, Bane did almost what I said a scum would do in that scenario. Not me. D) Pinda suspected him. And Nic and others even agreed that he was suspicious. E) He found Boba suspicious for the same reasons I did but didn't vote him in the end. Once Nic kept telling him not to, he listened. But Nic isn't always right no matter how loyal she is. It's almost like he was afraid to go against her that day. But even if he wasn't "afraid", perhaps he made it seem like he believed her at the moment, so he could vote me (a loyal with some suspicions) when Wampa (who was most likely gonna be voted) or Boba (who may also be voted) would come up loyal, making him appear like a smart loyal and perhaps allow Nic and the rest to follow him on voting me. That just seemed odd to me. A: Barely contributed? Bitch please. And yes I had fun with the Castiel roleplay. But how do you connect that with me trying to stay off people's suspicion list? B: "multiple times"? "Desperately"? Bitch please. I made my case as to why a double conviction would be a good thing and then tagged him at the end. I just wanted him to see it. Nothing more, or less, than that. C: Oh really? What do you mean by that? Because people say things like "I just think they're a better choice" all the time regardless of affiliation. D: Yup, because Loyal dead players are always right. I got ya. Stop treating Pinda's word as scripture any time it suits you. E: "Nic isn't always right no matter how loyal she is." I'm glad you understand how Pinda Could be wrong about me, then, because that's the logic you're using in Nic's case. And honestly yes I did but I wasn't willing to risk voting a loyal, who claimed a role. And no, I'm not afraid to go against her. I disagreed with her on the Pinda Newan vote and plus we had a argument and I didn't back down from that either. A: You didn't deny it. You barely even defended against it. B: That's the stupidest excuse I've ever heard. C: This makes no sense. I meant what I said. D: they aren't always right. But it seems pretty clear to me that you're scum. E: I do, just look at D for this part. You didn't back down? That doesn't mean much. Perhaps a scum trying to influence her to change her mind to what you think.
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 22:28:26 GMT -5
You didn't even post a defense for yourself! Kyronn took the chance to explain everything and to me he sounds pretty loyal. You've been pushing for double convictions too hard. And Kyronn will be voted tomorrow if you turn up loyal VOTE: BANE THE CONJUROR Been at work jsyk. Lol sure
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:30:19 GMT -5
It's actually true you can ask Malgus
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 22:31:47 GMT -5
1. Why did I vote Boba? I voted Boba because I felt that he probably lied to Nic about a role. Since she even said it wasn't protector basically once or twice, I began to feel that maybe Boba had lied to her so he could take advantage of her power and be trusted. This would greatly benefit the scum. Nic is also a newer player, so he probably would've had a better chance of fooling her. Bane even admitted the same thing happened to him his first time as inspector and he had more games under his belt before that too, so that supports what I said above even more. The fact that Nic was already in contact with 4 (5?) people by day 2 and thought they were all loyal continues to prove this. I just thought that she was probably trusting some too much. Another thing as well, is that Neean played similar to how he did last game (for deny that Bane. You said it yourself). So therefore, couldn't Boba have pulled another one of those claiming a role he doesn't have things again? Just another thought I had that led to me voting him. 2. Why did I think a double vote would be better? I thought it'd be better because, honestly, I didn't trust the role claims of Boba or Wampa. I just thought Wampa might be less of a threat if he was scum compared to Boba (since he was greatly trusted by Nic) along with all my thoughts for voting Boba in the above question. I mean, Wampa claiming like that seemed like a scummy move to me, but also, let me just say that it turned out he was a loyal. I could do the same thing he did and claim my role, but I *know* that everyone would think that it would make me seem scummier so that's why I haven't bothered. But the main point of why I thought a double vote would be better is because it'd give us more information like yesterday. Wampa and Bane supported it so much yesterday, and now Bane is acting like it's the worst idea ever. Wampa on the other hand... Was voted off as a result of another one and he was loyal. Don't make the same mistake with me. I'm loyal and thought a double conviction would help more, especially when I thought both suspects were almost equally suspicious. 3. Reasons I'm loyal A) I voted Newan early on. If I was scum, I wouldn't have done that, or at least waited a little longer. B) Assuming Newan was the killer (as there have been no deaths lately) wouldn't that make me less wanting to vote him? C) Not to mention that Pinda already had two votes when I voted Newan. If I was scum, I would've went with Bane and voted Pinda. Then Pinda would've had more votes. But I didn't, which would be a stupid move on my part if I was scum. D) Newan pushed for Pinda and me a lot. If I was scum, why would he push for me that much? I understand if he brought it up once or twice, but he constantly brought up how he was suspicious of me and thought I was scum. Scum wouldn't be that stupid to be the ones to always bring up suspicions against another member, especially when there was a bigger suspect (Pinda). E) Also, if I was scum, would I be so stupid as to do the whole "accuse the main one accusing you" thing? Cause apparently you think I'm doing that against Bane. But regardless of whether or not I am, that's be really predictable of a scum, also making me stupid. F) Potato was killed on night 1. That was obviously an attempt to frame me and Pinda. The scum were smart enough to realize that by killing Tater, it'd make Pinda suspicous (since he was kinda against/suspicous of Tater). It'd make me suspicous too, since Tater voted me and it'd make it look like I was trying to get back at the first person to bring up suspicions against me. It's just too obvious of something for me to do as a scum. My team wouldn't jepprdize me like that, especially that early on. If I was really scum, they probably would've killed another threat like Spider, etc. G) No one has been close to me this whole game (except maybe Pinda or Wampa *slightly*). So even if I'm voted, you won't have much of an idea of who to go for since I have no one close to me and pretty much everyone against me. Whereas if you voted someone else, at least they'd probably give you a better idea of who to go for next. 1. Yup, because Nic would have told the whole group that Boba actually claimed Protector. Who says that wasn't just a cover? Because that would be a good strategy. Also, it wasn't the first time I was inspector. It was another time. And Even if it was, I'm pretty sure that Nic is better than I was when I was just starting playing. See proven that Severus times to me in this game. Anyway, yes, I did say that about Newan. But while anyone can claim a fake role, I seen too many other people use Newan's strategy. 2. Wow, hinting at a role, classy. But really that just makes you seem more suspicious to me. And don't try and bend my words. I said nothing about being the worst idea ever. And anyway stop subtly pushing for me. If you have something to say, say it. 1. Well, it would've made me not vote Boba, for starters. Then he'd still be here. And I think it would've been safe to reveal that. The murderers obviously dead by now. Pinda never claimed a fake role...? 2. Like I said it would. And you proved my point. The way you feel about that towards me is how I felt about Boba and Wampa yesterday. But yet you choose to believe them, but not me. Scummy all the way. And I'm not bending your words. You just like to say that whenever I don't quote you word-to-word.
|
|
|
Post by Star on Jul 15, 2014 22:32:06 GMT -5
It's actually true you can ask Malgus This late though?
|
|
|
Post by ?6 (CBK) on Jul 15, 2014 22:33:25 GMT -5
It's actually true you can ask Malgus This late though? They have a different timezone I think
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:34:10 GMT -5
A: Barely contributed? Bitch please. And yes I had fun with the Castiel roleplay. But how do you connect that with me trying to stay off people's suspicion list? B: "multiple times"? "Desperately"? Bitch please. I made my case as to why a double conviction would be a good thing and then tagged him at the end. I just wanted him to see it. Nothing more, or less, than that. C: Oh really? What do you mean by that? Because people say things like "I just think they're a better choice" all the time regardless of affiliation. D: Yup, because Loyal dead players are always right. I got ya. Stop treating Pinda's word as scripture any time it suits you. E: "Nic isn't always right no matter how loyal she is." I'm glad you understand how Pinda Could be wrong about me, then, because that's the logic you're using in Nic's case. And honestly yes I did but I wasn't willing to risk voting a loyal, who claimed a role. And no, I'm not afraid to go against her. I disagreed with her on the Pinda Newan vote and plus we had a argument and I didn't back down from that either. A: You didn't deny it. You barely even defended against it. B: That's the stupidest excuse I've ever heard. C: This makes no sense. I meant what I said. D: they aren't always right. But it seems pretty clear to me that you're scum. E: I do, just look at D for this part. You didn't back down? That doesn't mean much. Perhaps a scum trying to influence her to change her mind to what you think. A: What? B: Okay then. C: And I mean what I say too let's have a sincerity party. D: Oh nice little comeback to that huge flaw in your evidence. E: Not backing down from the Inspector had everything to to with it.
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:34:34 GMT -5
It's actually true you can ask Malgus This late though? 4-9
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:35:27 GMT -5
And then I ate dinner I Won't apologize for that either.
|
|
|
Post by Newan on Jul 15, 2014 22:36:01 GMT -5
He works the graveyard shift.
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:37:23 GMT -5
I'm Not even going to talk to the scum anymore. If I try voted, it'll because they're scum votes and no loyal can get on in time not because anyone actually thinks I'm scum. Peace bitches
|
|
|
Post by bane on Jul 15, 2014 22:37:49 GMT -5
He works the graveyard shift. Lol not really.
|
|