Post by Potato on Jun 17, 2013 13:31:15 GMT -5
Conclusion Pictures: www.flickr.com/photos/93536940@N07/9069821164/
Congratulations to Mav, Squiggy, and Fisto on winning the Birthday Party Game! Great job guys! (And good job to Nam too, you gave them a lot of help!)
Thanks for playing everyone! You've given us all a great first year of the games, both the hosts and players alike. These really couldn't have been done without any of you, so thank you all. I hope you had a lot of fun playing, I had a lot of fun hosting despite some difficulties. I have sort of a lot to say that I'll slowly add as time goes by.
PLAYER FEEDBACK
Bane- You're definitely getting a lot better with every game. Honestly, I could see you as becoming a very big threat to a scum team any game now. And I guess you were seen as one this game because the scum murdered you. Anyway, like I said at the Graveyard, you were a pretty good protector. Most protectors just protect themselves the entire game, but you stepped it up and protected other people who you saw as important (and they were, you protected all Loyalists for the entire game). Really nice job!
Malgus- Great job! Like Bane, you're also improving. You were right with a lot of your votes in the day and you added some great opinions to the table! Sorry you could elaborate on your Loyal Knight role more. Too bad CBK couldn't play. I'll definitely make sure to use that role again.
CBK- I can't really say anything because you couldn't play. Sorry you couldn't be here, hopefully you'll come back soon!
Unlimited- Where are you? You were fairly active on the first day and then disappeared. Anyway, I can't really add too much because I think you were just here for the first half of day 1. I hope you'll come back soon!
Newan- Amazing job. Seriously, you took the role of leader and did a magnificent job at it. Honestly, I was fairly sure you guys would win for a lot of the time. The scum just really pulled themselves together at times. Anyway, you're an excellent leader and really did a great job at leading the Loyalists to a close victory. It's not all about winning or not, it's about playing well, and you played extremely well. Although, I wasn't exactly a fan of your crazy playing on Day 1.
Scruffy- You didn't do as bad as you might think. Yes, the scum had you manipulated at times, but you agreed with them for certain reasons, and you did explain why. I always like the evidence you bring up against players during games, too.
Killa- You did pretty well. I still think you can get better, but you were mostly with the right crowd of people and weren't manipulated too badly. And the scum did kill you for a reason, and that's because you looked loyal.
Ivar- You did pretty well. You're usually more of a follower, but it definitely helped out your team and made you a great asset to it. You did also add some new thoughts for everyone to take in, so that was good too.
Boba- First off, please don't take me killing you off the wrong way. I didn't mean anything against you and I really didn't want to kill you, but because you were practically confirmed as a Loyalist from that point on, and you had heavy suspicion too, it really gave the Loyalists an advantage. So in order to balance it out killing you was the best. Still, you're a lot more active then you were during your first couple games and that's a great improvement.
Nat- Good job as usual, although the scum did have you under their manipulation at times. You mostly are with the right crowd of people though, and with that you're always adding new opinions. So nice job!
Spider- Really great job again! You're right a ton of times with your suspicions and accusations, but I could actually see why everyone (even the loyals) were voting you off. But you do always eventually take the role of leader somehow and help everyone else push on to find the scum.
Kenobi- It's great that you're back to the games! It sort of sucks that you got voted off Day 1 though. I guess your vote was just a compromise between people like Pinda and Spider. I thought you still did well from what I saw from you on the first day, and considering it was Day 1 you probably would have continued to get better as the game progressed.
Pinda- Like I said at the Graveyard, it really sucks that you died just a couple days before all of your targets were killed. I was also really rooting for you to live for a while because I really liked your role and wanted to see it in action. If the scum didn't kill you on Day 1, people like Spider who you claimed to probably would have believed that your role was actually a loyal role. Anyway, you still did good, and my advice in your situation maybe would have been to be more subtle on the first day.
Mav- Congratulations on winning! Although you mostly just went with the crowd and sometimes defended people like Nam, that's what scum are supposed to do so I think it's safe to say that you did that very well. Good job!
Fisto- Nice first time as scum! You were quiet and didn't say a whole lot, but it helped you fly under the radar and in the end be trusted by some of the Loyalists. So even though you were quiet, being scum and being quiet while not being suspected is a good thing.
Squiggy- Like Fisto, you did a pretty good first time job as scum. You defending Nam is what really gave you away though, but you were still able to survive to the end and win it, so good job!
Nam- You played a good scum game as usual, and you sitting back on Day 1 while the Loyalists ripped each other apart was a good idea and I probably would have done the same. You were practically screwed when Spider was voted off, but I'm still sort of surprised that everyone just assumed he was Loyal even though he came up as Unknown. You still did well and really helped your team out well despite dying.
Loyalists- I thought you guys would win it for a lot of the time. You were organized, had powerful leaders, and weren't manipulated by the scum too badly. Even though you lost, still take into mind that a lot of you played really well.
Scum- Great job and congratulations on winning! I wasn't sure if you guys could pull it off, but you did. You all using your abilities at once was risky but worked out very well. Anyway, you all played equally well and contributed a great amount to your win.
Congratulations to Mav, Squiggy, and Fisto on winning the Birthday Party Game! Great job guys! (And good job to Nam too, you gave them a lot of help!)
Thanks for playing everyone! You've given us all a great first year of the games, both the hosts and players alike. These really couldn't have been done without any of you, so thank you all. I hope you had a lot of fun playing, I had a lot of fun hosting despite some difficulties. I have sort of a lot to say that I'll slowly add as time goes by.
PLAYER FEEDBACK
Bane- You're definitely getting a lot better with every game. Honestly, I could see you as becoming a very big threat to a scum team any game now. And I guess you were seen as one this game because the scum murdered you. Anyway, like I said at the Graveyard, you were a pretty good protector. Most protectors just protect themselves the entire game, but you stepped it up and protected other people who you saw as important (and they were, you protected all Loyalists for the entire game). Really nice job!
Malgus- Great job! Like Bane, you're also improving. You were right with a lot of your votes in the day and you added some great opinions to the table! Sorry you could elaborate on your Loyal Knight role more. Too bad CBK couldn't play. I'll definitely make sure to use that role again.
CBK- I can't really say anything because you couldn't play. Sorry you couldn't be here, hopefully you'll come back soon!
Unlimited- Where are you? You were fairly active on the first day and then disappeared. Anyway, I can't really add too much because I think you were just here for the first half of day 1. I hope you'll come back soon!
Newan- Amazing job. Seriously, you took the role of leader and did a magnificent job at it. Honestly, I was fairly sure you guys would win for a lot of the time. The scum just really pulled themselves together at times. Anyway, you're an excellent leader and really did a great job at leading the Loyalists to a close victory. It's not all about winning or not, it's about playing well, and you played extremely well. Although, I wasn't exactly a fan of your crazy playing on Day 1.
Scruffy- You didn't do as bad as you might think. Yes, the scum had you manipulated at times, but you agreed with them for certain reasons, and you did explain why. I always like the evidence you bring up against players during games, too.
Killa- You did pretty well. I still think you can get better, but you were mostly with the right crowd of people and weren't manipulated too badly. And the scum did kill you for a reason, and that's because you looked loyal.
Ivar- You did pretty well. You're usually more of a follower, but it definitely helped out your team and made you a great asset to it. You did also add some new thoughts for everyone to take in, so that was good too.
Boba- First off, please don't take me killing you off the wrong way. I didn't mean anything against you and I really didn't want to kill you, but because you were practically confirmed as a Loyalist from that point on, and you had heavy suspicion too, it really gave the Loyalists an advantage. So in order to balance it out killing you was the best. Still, you're a lot more active then you were during your first couple games and that's a great improvement.
Nat- Good job as usual, although the scum did have you under their manipulation at times. You mostly are with the right crowd of people though, and with that you're always adding new opinions. So nice job!
Spider- Really great job again! You're right a ton of times with your suspicions and accusations, but I could actually see why everyone (even the loyals) were voting you off. But you do always eventually take the role of leader somehow and help everyone else push on to find the scum.
Kenobi- It's great that you're back to the games! It sort of sucks that you got voted off Day 1 though. I guess your vote was just a compromise between people like Pinda and Spider. I thought you still did well from what I saw from you on the first day, and considering it was Day 1 you probably would have continued to get better as the game progressed.
Pinda- Like I said at the Graveyard, it really sucks that you died just a couple days before all of your targets were killed. I was also really rooting for you to live for a while because I really liked your role and wanted to see it in action. If the scum didn't kill you on Day 1, people like Spider who you claimed to probably would have believed that your role was actually a loyal role. Anyway, you still did good, and my advice in your situation maybe would have been to be more subtle on the first day.
Mav- Congratulations on winning! Although you mostly just went with the crowd and sometimes defended people like Nam, that's what scum are supposed to do so I think it's safe to say that you did that very well. Good job!
Fisto- Nice first time as scum! You were quiet and didn't say a whole lot, but it helped you fly under the radar and in the end be trusted by some of the Loyalists. So even though you were quiet, being scum and being quiet while not being suspected is a good thing.
Squiggy- Like Fisto, you did a pretty good first time job as scum. You defending Nam is what really gave you away though, but you were still able to survive to the end and win it, so good job!
Nam- You played a good scum game as usual, and you sitting back on Day 1 while the Loyalists ripped each other apart was a good idea and I probably would have done the same. You were practically screwed when Spider was voted off, but I'm still sort of surprised that everyone just assumed he was Loyal even though he came up as Unknown. You still did well and really helped your team out well despite dying.
Loyalists- I thought you guys would win it for a lot of the time. You were organized, had powerful leaders, and weren't manipulated by the scum too badly. Even though you lost, still take into mind that a lot of you played really well.
Scum- Great job and congratulations on winning! I wasn't sure if you guys could pull it off, but you did. You all using your abilities at once was risky but worked out very well. Anyway, you all played equally well and contributed a great amount to your win.