Epitaph - Day 3: Born Under a Bad Sign

They neither make them Scum

I read your defence. I can't say much about it and due to my inactivity though, but i see there really aren't any clear sign pointing to Scums or Loyals, however Bane seems fishy too me

Bet you didn't even read it.

I don't need too right now.

Well thank you for reading it at least. And I agree Nur is fishy. Along with Jones...

A few of you have said that I was scum due to my reasons for voting Whitaker. You still won't give that up, Nur also voted for Whitaker! Why aren't you putting him on trial! Everyone that voted Atlas can't be scum. I don't believe Nur is scum as much as I think you are, so it's a reason to vote you. If I was more inclined to vote Nur however, I'd have stated that as evidence about him to. Oh probably because you're all blinded by him. I voted Whitaker because I believed he wasn't speaking the truth. I thought, and so did Joe, he was purposely trying to reveal roles to benefit the scum. And I did not accuse Whitaker when he revealed inspector. I was just saying "You shouldn't have said that, now you are vulnerable for tonight." But obviously you look only at my negative reasons to voting him. What other reasons are positive considering he was loyal?  You all don't get it! We lost two loyals that day, along with Whitaker (Who I still don't care if he was third/loyal party). And Voldemort or Bob said how it wouldn't matter because we would have lost both Whitaker and Solo. But NO many of you voted for Joe who was infact loyal and spoke the same words I did about Whitaker. And now you want to blame me for Joe's sad demise when it was all YOUR faults. Since a lot of your wrath seems to be directed at me, I'll inform you that I did not vote for Joe and don't blame you for his death.  

I only accused Voldemort and Bob because those two led the votes against Joe. You would've done the same if you lost a friend to the votes. We did lose a friend. And I don't think I would have in your place. I was only trying to get answers. I really did think Bob was scum I admit. But many of you think I'm scum so it's no difference. And I was not trying to defend or back up Dark instead we agreed on a few things which is why we accused together (Something Treebeard Nur, and Jones are doing now accusing me.) But once I found out Bob had died! I rethought who I suspected because I realized I was wrong. And I am very sorry for accusing you Bob. Since I realized Bob was loyal it gave me to trust Voldemort a little more.

And for those who say I'm following him or he's "leading" these votes. Well guess what he's not! He has accused Nur for awhile now with Bob and now he's just leading it due to the same evidence that most of us have agreed on. He just voted him first, who cares! Maybe if some of you didn't let Voldemort question and discuss you could be the first to vote. And I'm not defending Voldemort I'm just pointing out the obvious which Treebeard, Jones, and Nur haven't seen. On the following part I have accused Voldemort and I have thought he was scum (What changed my mind was that he and Bob agreed on similar matters and now Bob was killed which wouldn't make sense if Voldemort was scum) He's the only one making actual sense with his accusations!!

And I am not accusing people with little evidence I have stated "I can't vote someone off without evidence." But you are accusing people with little evidence. Or at least "pointing out possibilities". You don't have to vote someone to accuse them, and that's what you're doing. That's something all of you should follow.

Why I suspect Jones is because he keeps following everyone, agreeing without even saying his own mind. (If you are loyal I'm deeply sorry for accusing you) He's been acting strange ever since I've accused him. He didn't post a defense which gives me the thought of him giving up. And he keeps trying to divert attention off of himself by randomly accusing others (The Rodian for example). In his defense that was more me he just said it was possible. 

Nur on the other hand I can see why he is suspicious but I defending him one time for voting Whitaker and now you don't even realize that he was more eager than I was to vote him off.

If you vote me off you'll lose once again another loyal all to Treebeards dumb accusations that he hasn't put any thought in! But now all of sudden Jones and Nur is following him probably so they can be "trustworthy". They voted and accused first... This group is failing! And I'm not accusing Treebeard at all I know he is a confirmed loyal. But he should at least inspect those who are suspicious Inspecting suspicious people NEVER works. They'll be protected by the leader if they're scum. Especially if they're suspicious. so he can stop hammering others about being potential scum.

Thank you.